Alright, this tutorial may not be all that helpful for anyone, but here goes anyways! I tried to find a picture that wasn’t necessarily one of my personal favorites, but one that would benefit from my method of processing the shot twice and then overlaying the two shots to mask the best parts of the shot together. Usually HDR will slaughter the sky and do great on object texture while DRI will do great on the sky while leaving a contrast to be desired on the main subjects. I also chose this shot because it demonstrates that I am not one of those photographers that is averse to editing crap out of the image that would detract from the scene. When I go out to take shots, I want to capture a scene in a way that is at least a little better than what the human eye is used to seeing. This means I have no qualms about editing out random objects that are out of place such as a branch or someones big head that you could just not find a way out of your composition.

This is the end result and it was taken on the observation deck of the Roppongi Tower, so there are quite a few smudges on the glass that are visible in the RAW shots and shooting through glass really amplified the drab pollution in the sky. Rather than bring my own bottle of Windex with me into the tower and waiting for 280 days when the weather finally blows all of the air pollution away and the sun comes out, I will use technology and be done with it! Again, I am not all that impressed with this shot at all, but maybe it will be at least helpful to see how I work on a real problem shot so 90% of your other shots will be a lot easier to process.

So if anyone ever wondered how the bracketed shots look before sending them to Photomatix, here are my original shots.. Very drab. If you were to spice them up with color and sharpening before exporting them to Photomatix, you will probably end up with a very strong HDR/DRI that may burn out your retina if you make direct eye contact with the shot. So about the only thing I ever chance would be the white balance if I didn’t nail it in camera, everything else can wait for Photoshop.

So first things first, the sky is the worst.. So I go straight to processing an HDRI shot since it tends to produce a much more natural looking sky than an HDR with its extreme propensity to halo the sky wherever it meets an object. Now the sliders will be different with every shot I process, but you can see the final settings I had set before processing with the sky as pretty much the only thing I was looking at since the rest of the shot will not be used almost at all.

Now I re-import my bracketed shots and start adjusting the HDR sliders until the city looks the way I want it and not caring at all how the sky looks since I will not be using any part of the HDR sky in the final shot. These sliders do stay more constant. Strength is always below 25%, Light Mode is always either Med or High, Microcontrast is set as high as I possibly can since this setting is what really gives you sharp looking textures. The Miscellaneous sliders almost always stay on 0% unless I am high on Skittles, which hardly ever happens..

So here we see a side by side of the processed HDR and DRI shots. You can see the city looks pretty bad in the DRI, but the sky looks a lot cleaner (at least on my monitor when I was processing it!) The HDR has the city buildings and roads looking a lot more how I would like them, but the sky looks like dirt. Let’s fire up Photoshop and open both shots.

Now you are going to bone up on your PS shortcut chops as I tell you how I create the layers. Go ahead and select the Move Tool and go to the photo that you want to be on the top of your layer. This should be the shot with the highest percentage of shot that is what you want in the final shot to save you some time masking out the bad parts. I will place the HDR on top since the city is the keeper part and it makes up about 80% of the shot. So I go to that shot and then hit Ctrl+a to highlight the entire shot. Now hold Ctrl+Alt and use your Left mouse button to drag a copy of the shot to the tab with the DRI. After you hover the mouse over the DRI tab, PS should now display the DRI shot. Now keep the Left mouse button selected and let go of Ctr+Alt. Now hit the Shift key and then you can finally let go of the the Left mouse button. I apologize for you Mac users, I do not know the shortcuts you need to use, but you should probably first ask Steve Jobs if he feels like allowing the use of shortcuts and hope he is feeling good that day.
The last step insured that the HDR will be placed directly over the center of the DRI shot. Sometimes Photomatix will crop each shot a bit differently, so you may have to go to the Layer Palette and drop the opacity of the top layer down to about 18% and use the Ctrl key and the Left mouse button to drag the shot around until it is perfectly lined up.
Next you will go over to your Layer Palette and select the little icon I have highlighted in the above shot, which is called Add Vector Mask. You will now see a white rectangle appear to the left of your top layer, if not, then you are fired.

If your are wondering what in the hell a vector mask is, well, we are going to process this photo like a boss the way Adobe engineers intended. We are going to get set up to start masking since the eraser tool is totally for artards.
So first go to the Foreground and Background boxes I highlighted on the bottom of my toolbar. These need to be black and white. You simply click on whichever box you want to change and select the color and hit okay. Now once we select the paint brush, we are set up to start masking, or what I like to call painting parts of the picture through. When you have the black color in front and your paintbrush set to 100% Opacity and Flow, you will erase 100% of the top part of the picture with your paint brush. Now when you hit the X button, white will now be the foreground color and every time you use the paintbrush you will paint back the top layer. So if you still have 100% opacity and Flow select and go over the spot you just erased, it will bring the part of the top lay back as if it was never erased.
Do you see how helpful this is for photography? If I make a mistake painting parts of a picture through, I simply hit X to bring white to the foreground, select about 20% opacity and bring back the spot that I erased too much of and I can then hit X again to select black and go back on my merry way painting through parts of the bottom layer. I usually work with low opacities to paint through slowly since it looks more natural rather than painting the bottom picture through 100%.

So on this shot, the two bottom boxes I highlighted are where you can see the abrupt transition where I painted through 100% of the bottom DRI layer to bring out the good sky. Now I need to drop my paint bursh opacity down to about 15% and make sure the Hardness of the brush is set to 0% and work on the transition of the sky into the city where the HDR portion begins. Dropping the hardness can be done by right clicking anywhere on the shot with the Paint Brush selected; you can also adjust the size of your brush with this little menu.
The top right box is where I highlighted the dirty glass with reflections. For this I will use my clone tool to completely erase evidence of such atrocities.

Now the hard part is over and we can start on the process of color correction and sharpening. If you are certain you are done masking, you will now want to right click a thumbnail in the Layer Palette and merge both layers together. Now I will hit Ctrl+M to bring up the curves tool. Adjusting RGB will change the contrast and selecting Red, Green, and Blue will of course help remove color casts or add one if you so desire. I removed a bit of a red and green cast and added a blue to help clean up the sky a bit more. The Tokyo sky can be a real bastard with the thick humidity in the air!

Next is my secret weapon, the Nik Software Suite. I feel that they currently make the best tools for sharpening a shot, removing noise, and converting to black and white. I will use Lightroom to sharpen a shot if I do not need to do anything else in Photoshop, but any shot that goes into PS will see the business end of the Nik Output Sharpener tool. I mostly leave everything set to default and just hit okay. Once it is done, it actually creates a layer and applies the changes to the top layer. Now you can select your eraser tool and desired opacity and erase any parts of the sharpening that you are not keen on. The program does such a good job that you rarely have to erase anything.
Now I would perform some noise removal with the Nik Software Dfine tool and erase parts you do not want to be softened. For this shot I erased all of the city from the top layer and let the sky be the only part of the shot with noise reduction. Now you will need to go to the Layer Palette again and merge all of these shot together. Next go to Image>Mode and select 8 Bits/Channel to be able to save your shot as a JPEG.